Q.5. Why do large cities tend to attract more migrants than smaller towns? Discuss in the light of conditions in developing countries. [UPSC 2024 GS P-1]

Large cities tend to attract more migrants than smaller towns for several reasons, especially in the context of developing countries. These cities offer better economic opportunities, access to services, and social advantages that are often lacking in smaller towns and rural areas. Below are some key reasons why large cities are more attractive to migrants, particularly in developing countries:

1. Economic Opportunities:

  • Jobs and Income: Large cities are typically economic hubs with a concentration of industries, businesses, and services. Migrants from rural areas or smaller towns are drawn to cities due to the higher availability of jobs in sectors such as manufacturing, construction, retail, and services.
  • Higher Wages: Cities often offer better-paying jobs compared to rural areas, where income opportunities may be limited to agriculture or small-scale enterprises. Migrants seek urban areas for wage employment, even if it involves low-skilled labor, as it generally offers a better income than their home regions.

2. Access to Services:

  • Healthcare and Education: Large cities generally have better healthcare infrastructure, including hospitals, specialized medical services, and clinics. They also offer more educational institutions, such as schools, colleges, and vocational training centers, which are scarce in rural or smaller towns.
  • Basic Amenities: Access to clean water, sanitation, electricity, and housing is often better in cities, despite challenges of urban poverty and slums. For rural migrants, these services may not be readily available in their home areas.

3. Better Infrastructure:

  • Transportation: Large cities usually have more developed transportation networks, including public transit systems, roads, and airports. This makes it easier for migrants to move around, find work, and access services. It also facilitates communication with family members in their home regions.
  • Communication Networks: Cities have better internet connectivity, access to telecommunications, and other forms of media. These are critical for job search, education, and maintaining social connections.

4. Diversified Economy:

  • Large cities have a diversified economy, which means migrants can find employment in various sectors, from informal markets (street vending, small-scale businesses) to formal industries (corporate jobs, factories). This diversity provides greater resilience during economic downturns and offers multiple avenues for income generation.
  • Entrepreneurial Opportunities: Urban areas offer a conducive environment for entrepreneurship due to better access to credit, markets, and customers. Migrants may start small businesses or join the informal economy, which is often vibrant in large cities.

5. Social Networks and Support Systems:

  • Existing Migrant Communities: Many large cities already have established migrant communities from various regions, making it easier for new migrants to integrate. These communities offer social support, housing, and information about job opportunities, helping newcomers adjust to urban life.
  • Family Reunification: Often, families migrate in phases, with one member moving to the city first and others joining later. This creates a pull factor for migrants to follow their relatives and settle in the same urban area.

6. Perceived Improvement in Quality of Life:

  • Social Mobility: Large cities are seen as places where individuals have better chances of upward social mobility. The allure of a better standard of living, consumer goods, entertainment, and a more cosmopolitan lifestyle often attracts migrants from rural areas or small towns, even if the reality involves significant hardship.
  • Escape from Rural Poverty: Many migrants view cities as an escape from the cycles of rural poverty, where limited access to land, low agricultural productivity, and lack of modern services create difficult living conditions.

7. Agrarian Distress and Lack of Opportunities in Rural Areas:

  • In developing countries, agricultural distress, such as poor yields, droughts, floods, and lack of market access, drives many rural inhabitants to seek alternative livelihoods in cities. Unemployment or underemployment in rural areas, compounded by lack of technological advancements and mechanization, contributes to migration.
  • Land Fragmentation: In many developing countries, as population growth leads to fragmentation of agricultural land, rural people find it difficult to sustain themselves on shrinking landholdings. Cities offer alternatives to this.

8. Better Governance and Public Services:

  • Large cities often attract more government funding and international investments for infrastructure, social services, and urban development. As a result, people migrate to cities where public services such as healthcare, education, and transportation are perceived to be better than in smaller towns or villages.
  • Political Representation: Urban residents may have better access to political representation and public services, creating a sense of better inclusion in governance.

9. Push Factors in Smaller Towns and Rural Areas:

  • Limited Economic Growth: Smaller towns in developing countries often lack industries or the capital investment required for significant economic growth. Many of these towns are dependent on local agricultural production or small-scale businesses, limiting employment opportunities.
  • Stagnant Social Environment: Social mobility and educational opportunities are often limited in small towns, leading ambitious individuals to migrate to larger urban centers for better prospects.

10. Globalization and Urbanization Trends:

  • Foreign Investments: Large cities, particularly in developing countries, tend to attract more foreign direct investments (FDI) due to better infrastructure, skilled labor pools, and market size. This increases job creation and economic activities, further pulling migrants.
  • Urbanization Policies: Governments in developing countries often promote urbanization through policies that favor industrial and infrastructural development in large cities. As a result, cities grow disproportionately faster than smaller towns, making them magnets for migrants.

Conclusion:

In developing countries, large cities offer better economic prospects, access to services, and infrastructure that are often lacking in smaller towns and rural areas. These factors, combined with existing social networks and the perception of improved quality of life, make cities attractive destinations for migrants. However, this trend also leads to urban challenges like overcrowding, inadequate housing, slum development, and pressure on public services. Despite these challenges, cities continue to serve as key destinations for migrants seeking better livelihoods and opportunities.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *